Blog Layout


Breaking (or creating) the cycle: The challenge of habits in behaviour change

Is there anything in your life that you do repeatedly, whether that's monthly, weekly or several times a day, that you do a certain way? Something you do on autopilot, without a lot of thought?

Of course there is.

Have a think about these tasks - do you follow the same routine every time?


  • Doing a weekly supermarket shop in store - do you tend to buy the same brands of food, shampoo etc. each time? Explore the store in the same way?
  • Which stores do you visit – is it the same supermarket? Petrol station? Café on the way to work?
  • Putting your shoes and socks on - are you a sock/sock/shoe/shoe person or a sock/shoe/sock/shoe? Do you always start with the same foot?
  • Doing the dishes - do they pile up on the bench, or in the sink? Do you rinse before putting them in the dishwasher? Does the dishwasher go on at the same time each day? Do you empty it straight away or when you're next getting a meal prepared?


For the tasks we've mentioned above, there is no right or wrong way to do them. If your pantry’s stocked, your car is topped up with petrol (unless you’ve taken the socially minded EV route), you've got your shoes and socks on and a kitchen of clean dishes* - you've succeeded. But the way we each go about doing these tasks is generally so engrained in us, that we do them without thinking.

 

*We do acknowledge the many domestic arguments that can come from different household members having a different routine for these tasks. If you're a 'dishes do NOT go in the sink' person living with a 'dishes go in the sink until I'm ready to deal with them' person, I feel you. ^SG


And that’s great. By performing these tasks on autopilot we’re able to direct our attention – and our limited headspace – to more important topics.

 

Imagine now you're a retail store, trying to change the way people walk around your shop, a contact centre manager, trying to get your team to reduce call handling times by a few seconds, or an FMCG brand trying to increase purchase of your products. Or maybe you work hard all day, you're tired and you just don't want to see a sink full of dirty dishes when there is an empty dishwasher waiting nearby.

 

In each of these situations, you're trying to change someone's behaviour, and likely to come up against someone’s existing habits. 

So what is a habit?

Essentially, a habit is a behaviour that you perform in the same way, in response to specific situations every time. It’s an automatic and inflexible response, and although it may have started out as a choice, it’s become an engrained habit through repetition.


When you first performed the behaviour, it would have taken more brain power and thought, but through the repetition, over time, the behaviour is now performed with little conscious thought.

How do habits get formed?

Charles Duhigg, an American writer, coined 'the habit loop' in his 2014 book 'The power of habit', from a simple neurological loop discovered by MIT researchers. The idea is that there are three key stages involved in forming every habit, and once you've identified each component, you can then start to work on changing the habit.

Diagram showing the habit loop, with the words 'cue', 'routine' and 'reward' with arrows going around making it a circular process

Cue: This is what kicks off the habit behaviour, the 'thing' that starts the chain of events. Cues could be: location, time, emotional state, other people and the immediately preceding action.


Routine: The most obvious part of the loop, and the behaviour that you are looking to change.


Reward: The reward is the craving the behaviour satisfies. 


For example, every morning I sit down in my office to start work [cue] with a cup of coffee (black no sugar) and read The Spinoff’s Bulletin email [routine], which gives me a sense of contentment and control [the reward]. There is little thought, it simply occurs automatically in response to the time and location.

What are the challenges of habits?

The key challenge of habits - for anyone wanting to change one - is that they occur subconsciously, and they can occur long after their utility has waned. As an example, I once did a lot of training to complete the NZ Ironman (2015 … it was before kids), which required a lot of food intake. Unfortunately, after Ironman – when I stopped training – the food habit continued and my weight ballooned.


The habit continued long after the requirement for all those extra calories had disappeared.


From a different perspective, I recently moved house and now have a 10min walk to a ferry terminal. This ferry could take me across the water to Hobsonville Point, a new suburb in which several members of my family live. While I knew the ferry was there, by habit, I consistently put my kids in the car and took a much longer commute to visit family. It wasn’t an issue of awareness, it was a habit that had outlived it’s usefulness.

How do you create a new habit?

The idea behind the habit loop is that once you have identified what triggers the behaviour, the reward it provides, and the behaviour itself, you can begin to adapt it. Through experimentation you can find a behaviour that triggers the same emotional response (reward) as the original.


If there is a new habit you want to create - e.g. bringing your lunch to work instead of buying it, or going to the gym every day - you need to create the cue and reward that will set you up for success.


For example, to build an exercise habit could you leave your shoes by the bed (the cue) to trigger a run in the morning (the routine), which finishes at your local café for a coffee (the reward)?

What about breaking a habit?

The approach we've outlined above relies on new habit formation - what if you would instead like to simply break a habit? Perhaps stop customers from leaving clothes on the changing room floor, or stop employees from talking over others and interrupting in meetings.

 

In this instance, the science of habits would tell us that we should remove the cue that causes our customers or employees to perform the related behaviour, or replace it with a competing cue. Do customers leave clothes on the floor because there aren't enough hooks? Try a clothing bin just outside the doorway. Are employees interrupting because they don't feel they usually get enough time to share their ideas? Try changing the meeting format!


But one of the biggest opportunities is some disruption to our existing routines. Moving house, changing jobs, getting married or having a child, as examples, are all changes that might allow us to create new, or replace old, routines.


A good example comes from the UK … during the 2014 London underground strike some, but not all, of the networks underground stations were forced to close. This meant some commuters were forced to look for new routes while others were able to continue as normal. After strikes finished, 5% of disrupted commuters continued with their new routines – the new habit had stuck.


Perhaps that’s why we’re seeing some organisations coming through the past two-years of COVID disruptions (e.g., lockdowns, working from home) stronger. Through intent or luck, they’ve been able to align themselves with the new habits of their users.

Want to know more?

If you're interested in learning more about habits, get in touch or follow us on LinkedIn.


Main Photo by Social Mode on Unsplash

By Cole Armstrong September 4, 2024
In recent discussions about customer behaviour, a recurring theme has emerged: the belief that providing more information will lead to better decision-making (“If only they knew … then they would …”). While this perspective isn't entirely misplaced, it overlooks a crucial nuance. It's not merely what people know that drives their behaviour, but rather what information is most salient and readily springs to mind in the moment of decision. The Limitation of Knowledge Alone It's easy to assume that if customers simply knew more, they would make better decisions. For instance, knowing how to budget effectively or save money can indeed be useful. Knowing that I should save more for retirement or for investments. That I should eat less red meat for health or sustainability reasons. That I should be careful about what information I share online. These are all real-life examples of issues I’ve worked on where educating customers (or users) might have been a solution – and where helping people ‘know’ why they should do it failed to shift the needle. The critical factor isn't just having the information, but rather how accessible and prominent that information is when it’s needed. The question then is not do I know something, but rather does it spring to mind when it can actually shape my decisions? The Salience of Information in Decision-Making Consider a scenario where a customer interacts with a product or service. The decision-making process is often instantaneous and intuitive, driven by what immediately comes to mind rather than a comprehensive evaluation of all known benefits. This means that the information most salient at the moment—whether it's the immediate cost or a specific feature—has a more significant impact than the general knowledge a customer might have. As an example, I was involved in a project where my client was responding to new environmental regulations – and wanted to find out how to do this without upsetting their customers. The initial solution didn’t work because what was salient – and thus impacted customers responses – was the benefit to the brand not the benefit to the environment. While both benefits were ‘known’ by customers, it wasn’t till small tweaks were made to subtly emphasise and customer support for such actions, that complaints dropped off. A Case in Point: Council Rates Another example where this idea is relevant are the rates (tax) bills that New Zealanders receive from their local council. While residents might be well aware of the benefits their rates support—such as parks, libraries, and community services—this knowledge doesn’t always translate into a positive reaction when the bill arrives. For many, the first thing that springs to mind is the expense, not the benefits. In my case, receiving a $1,000 council rates bill (these are billed quarterly) was a stark reminder of this phenomenon. Despite understanding the value provided by these rates, the immediate focus was on the financial burden. If the benefits were more salient at the time of billing, the experience could be more positive. For instance, if the rates bill included a summary of the value received from various services—like a breakdown showing the value I obtain from the library based on the number of books borrowed—this could shift the focus from the cost to the benefits. In my case, borrowing 35 books over three months at an estimated value of $30 each amount to $1,050 worth of benefits, which highlights the value received far beyond the cost. And of course there are other services that I use as well – my local park that I go running in, the playgrounds that I take my kids to, the roads I drive along or the public transport that is subsidised. I ‘know’ these things, but do they immediately spring to mind when I see my rates bill? Seizing the Opportunity This concept of salience extends beyond council rates. In various customer interactions—such as bills, invoices, loyalty schemes, and product renewals—the opportunity lies in enhancing the salience of positive attributes at the critical moment of engagement. To effectively leverage this understanding, organisations should focus on making the benefits of their products or services more prominent when customers are most engaged and in a way that is relevant to the context. This means designing communications and touchpoints that highlight the value received, not just the cost or features.  While knowledge is important, it's the salience of that knowledge at the moment of decision that truly influences behaviour. By ensuring that the most relevant and positive information is top-of-mind, organisations can improve customer satisfaction and decision-making outcomes.
By Cole Armstrong July 24, 2024
Navigating the Shifting Landscape of Design
By Cole Armstrong March 15, 2024
How do we create persuasive touchpoints that make a difference? By considering how simple ways of reframing our messages, using insights from psychology and behavioural science, can create greater motivation to act.
Show More
Share by: